3 Colours Review – The Mantic Paint Set
September 18, 2011 by elromanozo
Everyone here acknowledges Mantic Games as the alternative to the major games in our hobby, with affordable miniatures and a fast growing range of games... Not many people know they do paint sets as well.
All right, they're not actually producing the paints... They're the Army Painter range, Warpaints, but they pack them in quite well.
And packed they are... The Mantic paint sets are all DVD-esque boxes that will fit in your shelves (a brilliant idea), just like the packaging for their miniatures, and they're bursting with content. I'm not kidding, I couldn't put everything back in the box after opening it, until I removed the cardboard bit that was holding some of the paint pots, to make some room!
The largest Mantic paint set has nine paint pots, a decent brush, and three plastic sprues which allow you to build six miniatures.
Oh, there's also a leaflet that's merely advertisement. It contains an amusing "painting guide" comprising of a few sentences, basically saying "glue your minis, prime them, then paint them, go to the Mantic website for details"... But no one believes you can learn proper painting by studying half a sheet of paper anyway.
The brush is quite good... It's a basecoating brush from the Army Painter "hobby" range : Its synthetic hair will last just as long as the Citadel brushes (if not longer), and it'll keep its point better... Watch out for my review about this very interesting brush range.
The miniatures aren't any exclusives, they're your basic Mantic miniatures... But you do have a lot of them, and they're quite varied... A nice surprise, as paint sets either provide no miniatures at all, or a single one, or, at best, few miniatures of a single type!
You have enough parts to build two ghouls or zombies, two skeletons and two elves... What I like about them is that you have enough spare parts to truly have options when building the minis! You're not forced to accept the basic pose, you actually have accessories and different arms and bodies to choose from, as well as extra bases !
This set also provides nine paint pots... That's one more than the beginner Games Workshop sets. Furthermore, the pots are drop bottles, eminently practical, and with more paint in them than the pots in the Citadel range.
It's also a very general selection (black, white, red, green, brown, blue, flesh, silver and gold). They're hardly the best paints in the world, but they are just right for the beginner and the layman (see my soon to be published in depth review about Warpaints), and, most of all, liquid enough that it doesn't matter much if you don't dilute them.
As you can see, with this paint set, you're not stuck with the usual "just the colors you need to paint the one species included in the set"... you have options about the colours you want to use, and also about the minis you build. This is what a paint set should be like!
Finally, a sufficiently generic paint set, non themed, ideal for introducing children to the hobby, But it's also perfect for someone on a budget, who wants a basic selection of paints and minis to see what he'll be collecting and painting later on.
Indeed, the value for money is excellent, as per usual with Mantic: you get that large paint set (the largest of the Mantic ones, in fact) for slightly cheaper than the smallest Games Workshop paint set... which contains fewer (smaller) paint pots, fewer miniatures, a terrible brush and no options.
... and of course, you get a Mantic Point with your purchase, to help you get more Mantic goodness.
If you ask me, that's an excellent deal!
Supported by (Turn Off)
Supported by (Turn Off)
Supported by (Turn Off)
I find the Gold paint quite useful! This is a very good deal!
Yes, as I said, not the best paint in the world, but it does the job nonetheless !
BoW Romain
I bought myself this set to try out some non gw paints and also to see mantics figures…its a great deal and the paints are pretty good.
These days I would look hard at the paints from Vallejo for a better quality set. I look forward to a report on why you (Romain) like one set over another etc
@elromanozo are you going to do a round-up and comparison piece when you’ve been through all the paint ranges individually? While I can go and compare the scores from each one myself, it would be nice to have a guide to really make sense of them. What do you think are the real points of comparison and on what features do you think I should base my choice of what paints to buy?
This is an interesting question… Perhaps I’ll do that at some point… But there’s always going to be a brand I forgot or didn’t review, so it’s bound to be incomplete. Besides, it all depends on what you’re looking for : Some painters just want a no-hassle paint that you don’t have to dilute and gives a good tabletop result in few coats and little time, some painters want the extra matte paints for advanced texturing, some need fine pigments for airbrushing, some would like vivid fantasy colors even for their most tame pieces, whereas some would prefer subdued ones… Read more »
All true, and accepted. You will never be able to review all of them, nor satisfy everyone’s personal peccadilloes. However, you could perhaps address some of the more obvious approaches.
Just a thought, and one that would not be appropriate till you’d finished the series on individual lines anyway. Something for the backbrain to chew on 🙂
Believe me, I’ve been chewing on that one ever since i began those reviews…
But thanks for pointing all that out !
BoW Romain
I agree, quirkworthy. I’d like to see a summary as well. I really enjoy your reviews Romain. They are informative and useful. Thank you!
also worth bearing in mind, that being Army Painter paints they are primarily designed to be used with the AP system.
I have recently been painting some units of Orcs for Mantic using just these paints, and although a very basic range, they produce surprisingly pleasing results when combined with a suitable base spray (Leather Brown & Fur Brown in my case), quickshade and anti-shine 🙂
Also worth noting that Mantic also have ‘Armour’ and ‘Bone’ colours available, which would be well worth adding to this starter set if you order it… especially if you intend to paint a lot of skeletons/revenants!
Very true… I haven’t talked about the paints in detail here, but watch out for my specific review on the Army Painter Warpaints !
BoW Romain
I want to move on from Citadel Colors to a painting range thats best for painting to competition standard. Can somebody recommend a brand please? Vallejo maybe??
My paint reviews are written just for that purpose : to provide valuable information about alternatives. Citadel makes good paint in their own right, and I know many painters who use them for competitions with great success (including Slayer Sword winners, and so on)… The key here is to use them wisely, and turn their flaws into qualities… As with all brands. Most of the truly awesome painters I know use a great many brands of paints at the same time, on the same miniature, depending on the exact tone, texture, glossiness, saturation, effect, etc. they’re looking for. It all… Read more »
Thanks Romain! Some great tips there. Ive read all your reviews thus far and i think im gonna look into some more matt finishing type paints. I think Vallejo will be where i will start with a small purchase of basic colors i find myself using the most. Thanks once again and keep up the good work dude!
Thanks a lot for your compliments !
I find P3 is excellent, but Valljo is admittedly more varied and often readily available… You might want to buy a few of both ranges before reaching a decision : You’ll be better informed, and it’s unlikely you’ll regret any purchase from those two brands.
BoW Romain