@evilstu (35 points)

Regarding your points:

(1) I fear there is already a perception of elitism and exclusivity with these threads sadly. The subject has been broached with me by a couple of members. I think we, on this thread, need to participate more in other threads rather than have this be seen as a ‘Club’. They aren’t too wrong either, I guess. Theres been a lot of history with this thread. Good and bad. While we have been keeping it going and keeping a more positive vibe up, I think we kind of need to make it our mission to include ourselves in the rest of the forums some more, interact with others outside of here, as well as be encouraging and welcoming.

(2) I don’t think there can or should be too many guildelines. End of the day, a lot of hosting is down to personal taste. That both does and doesent work for everyone, but if you are the one putting aside your time and putting in the effort to host then it kinda should be that way to a degree. Brief but not strict guidelines however could be good. Or even if its down to members liking something, generating XP automatically and giving a total by a date that works too.

(3) That may help but its down to whoever has a say in that. Interest in the thread as well as activity in it has dipped for some time. Im not sure if it would work or help.

(4) Buttons work I think. It would be cool to have. Maybe do a button only tester and see how it goes.

Thanks for all the suggestions. 30 points.

***

Response to your second post:

That also works for AoS. There are some good entry points for AoS with prices and sets. The models aren’t even alternatives, those little warbands have rules for AoS. Yep, Manflayers, 5 points.