Are These Your Top Five Board Games?
September 29, 2013 by crew
Monopoly, Cluedo, Risk.
All games that we have played in our past at one time or another around the family table or with friends. Now you're all grown up and a hobbyist, you’ve noticed a group of people at your local hobby shop all sat down around a board game and the hairs on the back of your neck stand up as you feel all those fuzzy warm memories of board games of times past.
Gaming has evolved over the last 15 years and like war games and card games, times change and new products hit the shelves each and every year. But I digress, you’ve decided to read this article because you’re interested in joining that group of board gamers, you want to play some of the more “mainstream” board games that are currently being played by the board game crowd. So sit back, relax, and let me take you through what are currently considered to be, by most, the top 5 board games.
Set in a dystopian future filled with bio-tech, androids and megalomaniacal corporations all plotting for superiority in a world where money means everything, Netrunner is a two player LCG that plays in a very unique way to any other card game you’ve seen. 'LCG?' I hear you ask. Well a LCG is a Living Card Game, and it is the most amazing thing to be thought up for the card game community. Unlike blind booster card games like Magic the Gathering where you never know what you’re going to get, an LCG releases “chapter packs” which will always include the same cards. This ensures no card, no matter how powerful, will be harder to get than any other. The game itself focuses on two players where one player is the corporation player and the other players the runner. The idea of the runner’s game is to steal cards to score seven points and win the game. The corporation’s method of victory is to score seven points of kill the runner. The game is deep and enjoyable with a real tactical insight into the moves you need to make to ensure victory and not fall into the traps of the other player.
4) Puerto Rico
What people consider to be the defining euro game that set in motion the movement of the same name in the board game world. Puerto Rico is a role selection game that involves the purchase and working of farm land and the running of a thriving city all at the same time. A worker placement game that is deep and tactical with many different strategies that keep the game fresh with a high replay factor. The main aim of the game is to create resources with your farmland which you then sell to the many ships coming to port. You then use those funds to create buildings in your city and score victory points. As with most, if not all, euro games, after a set number of turns, the player with the most victory points will be declared the winner. This is a long running game that has been on the shelves for a long time and will always be a stalwart choice for new or veteran board gamers.
3) Through the Ages: A Story of Civilisation
Through the ages has been a strong game since its introduction with a very interesting method of play that requires a strategic and calculating mind. The basic idea of the game is to create and run your own civilisation, helping it to grow and thrive through natural events of the world. This will test your endurance and reward your good work. While maintaining your civilisation you have to expand it, allowing you to grow which will further you along the track to victory. Does your empire require religion? Or should it take its time and make sure it has a foothold in philosophy first? Is it wise to make sure agriculture is attained early or can you afford to wait a few turns? These are the kinds of questions you will have to deal with when you are constructing your thriving civilisation.
2) Agricola
A popular game mainly due to the interesting game pieces you get to use. The idea of this game is to create a farm, to grow produce, raise and sell animals and look after a family in the tough world of the farmyard empire. You buy pieces of fence and animals and create, on a small board, your own little farmstead. You grow your vegetables and you breed your animals, then sell them on to fund even more produce and even more animals, all while ensuring your crops don't spoil and your animals don’t die or run away. Oh and to make things worse you have to keep your family alive so they can tend your land as well which isn’t as easy as it sounds.
Almost considered to be a war-game this game focuses on an almost risk style gaming experience where two players face off reliving the iconic cold war era. One player plays Russia while the other plays the U.S.A. With varying hands of cards, the idea of the game is to take control of areas of the globe in an attempt to ensure your influence in that part of the world keeping the area under your control. Cards are used to do everything from placing influence, attempting coups in opponents controlled areas, scoring and so on. With two different ways to win the game is both in- depth and tactical with a focus on smart decision making at the right time. If your interested in the cold war era the cards are also very flavourful in that each is some sort of historic event during the period and interacts with other cards in much the same way the events unfolded at the time.
So there you have it, what I and some of the board game community considers to be the top five games at this time. Now there are many different games out there for you to try from zombie survival games, dexterity and party games, all the way to memory games and backstabbing loyalty driven games. The board game community is so vast and diverse that I can assure you there will be a game out there for you to enjoy. So sit down, grab a drink and dive into the friendly board game community.
What would be on your top five board game list?
If you would like to show off your top five board games or write an article for Beasts of War then please contact me at [email protected].
Top 5? That’s pretty hard to narrow down (though BGG’s ratings probably come as close to a consensus as we’re ever going to, at least in the top 100). That Ticket to to Ride isn’t included in this list is a gross oversight. I don’t know of any other game that is as immediately accessible and yet still engrossing for years to come. It’s easily the best board game designed in the last decade, elegant even. Also Netrunner, as an LCG, really isn’t a board game in any meaningful sense. It requires expansions to be truly playable (a couple of… Read more »
I’d second mpopke’s puzzlement over Netrunner’s appearance in this list. I don’t consider it a boardgame. No issue with Twilight Struggle at #1.
Netrunner is a good LCG/CCG, though of its format I’d be inclined to personally rank the hybrid deck builder/CCG High Command higher, or even Call of Cthulhu LCG. Either way, it doesn’t quite belong on this list.
My current list of top five board games tends to hold a lighter weight than normal due to increased time working, war gaming and LARPing, though it tends to rotate often anyways.
5. Cthulhu Fluxx
4. Onirim
3. Arkham Horror
2. Hive
1. Space Hulk:Death Angel
I would say:
1-Twilight Imperium
2-War of the Rings
3-Arkham Horror
4-Puerto Rico
5-Carcassonne
I’m a big fan of TI. In fact, games with the world Twilight in are the best lol
Hey all. Writer here. Just wanted to put a quick point out there to you all who seem to have issue or disagree with this top 5 i just want to make it clear this isnt my personal top five favourite board games. This is the current top 5 on the boardgamegeek website which is highly regarded as the #1 place for boardgame related stuff. As such this is based on the ratings of ten of thousands of gamers such as yourself. i personally dont agree with half the listings but this is the current trend. P.S mpopke :- i… Read more »
Well BGG isn’t strictly board games. They list Warmachine (and other minis games) on there too. Eclipse gets the number 5 spot if you filter out CCGs. I’m kind of surprised how much BGG has changed in the last year. Most of the games I remember being in the top 100 have been replaced (Dune used to be rated somewhere around #7 I think, Ticket to Ride was in the top 25). BGG’s ratings used to be a lot more stable over time than they have been lately. There are a few possible explanations for this: 1) Their rating algorithm… Read more »
The old don’t shoot the messenger response.
I suggest not crossing the bridge if you don’t like Trolls, Nick
Anyway, I like were Beasts is going with more content on Boardgames in general.
Don’t let then get you down, keep writing.
I get that though it’s still a little misleading to present the article as the top five boardgames. The top five tabletop games as currently rated on BGG might have been a better way of presenting it. Given I can that list anytime, I’d be more interested in reading your top five boardgames 🙂
Yes, sure, but it’s so nice to make personal top five lists 🙂
Had a lot of fun with spartacus, the new risk and fiasco so I’m not sure I can agree with this top 5 as these 3 games are only my most played of this year. The baron munchuasen (bad spelling I know lol)role play game is a bloody good laugh as well.
Ps also agree with the ticket to ride comments.
Thanks all for the critique . Just if anyone was curious my top five would be as follows
5) Risk Legacy
4) Power Grid
3) 7 Wonders
2) Sid Meiers Civilisation
1) Lords of Waterdeep
What !!!!
No Junta !
Fantastic game with 7 players. 🙂
Viva El Presidente !!
Not a great fan of junta i much prefer puerto rico fort that style of game
well guess i’ll have to weigh in on this one:
1. Spartacus (great fun scheaming and plotting against friends)
2. Firefly (it’s Firefly… nuff said…)
3. lords of water deep (a great tactical game simple as can be and a good laugh)
4. blood bowl (a classic that will never go out of style)
5. libertalia (Light easy and funny as hell when you play your brute!)
My current top 5 sits at:
#1: Agricola
#2: Eclipse
#3: Le Havre
#4: Puerto Rico
#5: Race for the Galaxy
I could see Terra Mystica break into the top 5 with more plays.
I enjoyed the article, but I think one thing really missed the mark. My very biased opinion thinks your initial Agricola statement “A popular game mainly due to the interesting game pieces you get to use.” was pretty far off base. Suggesting the game made it to #2 because people liked playing with wooden farm animals really does not do the game justice.
I own and manage a gaming store that primarily runs off board game sales and also hosts many games nights during the week. Going by sales, requests and frequency of play on our tables here…here’s my top 5: 5) King of Tokyo 4) Bioshock 3) Summoner Wars 2) Super Dungeon Explore 1) Zombicide I have tried stocking Catan, Carcassonne and they seldom – if ever – sell. I have tried drumming up interest in games such as Agricola and Puerto Rico – again, zero interest. It puzzles me how these games get so highly rated when the vast majority of… Read more »
1. Descent ; journeys in the dark 2nd edition w/ expansions
2. High Command (pushing to number one rather quickly) Privateer Press
3. King of Tokyo (A hit with the family)
4.Zombicide
5. Upper Deck Legendary Marvel Deck Building Game
Heres a cool video I really like these guys
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h-8k9Auuw5g
1. King of Tokyo
2. Pandemic
3. Castle Panic
4. Star Trek Catan
5. Ticket to Ride
These are the top games in our family.
5. Gloom
4. Zombicide
3. Settlers of Catan
2. Pandemic
1. Elder Sign
I like all of the games on this list. I’m a big fan of Munchkin as well, but we tend to have more than four people playing. Munchkin starts to suffer when you have too many people as the game starts to drag. Elder Sign is definitely my top pick. I love how it’s never the same exact game twice.
I’d say deck-building isn’t strictly “boardgame”, but hey, it counts…
My top (subject to variations according to my mood) :
1) Smallworld
2) Dominion
3) Pandemic
4) Dominion
5) Dixit
6) Spartacus (only so low because it hasn’t been translated into french yet)
7) Race for the Galaxy
8) Werewolves of Miller’s Hollow (only so low because it requires 8 players)
9) Settlers of Catan
10)Ticket to ride
I’m going to go out on a limb here and say that you’re in the mood for Dominion more often (approximately twice as often) as the other games on your list. I see Lords of Waterdeep on a lot of lists now (not just here). I think I’m going to have to give it a try sometime.
Nope, I’m not. It’s just easier ot set up and explain. I’m usually in a Dixit mood, or even Once Upon a Time, but people around me find that less interesting, so I’ve all but stopped playing.
Hm. It’s hard to narrow down a top five. I can tell you Agricola won’t be anywhere near it though. Farming games. *shakes head in bewilderment*
My current list (subject to change on a whim):
5: Robo Rally
4: Axis & Allies (Anniversary edition and the new WWI version are my favorites)
3: Battletech
2: Commands & Colors (I’m just going to lump Ancients and Napoleonics into one)
1: Leviathans
Honorable mentions include: Dominion, 7 Wonders, Power Grid, Space Hulk, King of Tokyo, Wings of War/Glory, Railways of the World, and Conflict of Heroes.
A top 5 list of board games usually depends on context. I think that in a general, Tabletop-show kind of way, this would be the top 5 right now, in no particular order: 1. Settlers of Catan 2. Ticket to Ride 3. Arkham Horror 4. Pandemic 5. Carcassonne Those are games that even people who haven’t tried modern board games have heard of somewhere, or know someone who plays them. For example, whenever someone brings up board games in a videogame stream chat, someone else always mentions Arkham Horror. My own top 5 would be, again in no particular order:… Read more »
Having not played any of the 5 games in the original post I don’t feel qualified to pass judgement. But, like all of us here, I have my own list of favourite games that I’ve played over the years. This is based purely on the amount of fun I’ve had playing each one, and this is as much a factor of the great folks I played with as the game itself. So here goes: No 1. Civilisation (the Avalon Hill or Gibson Games variant from the 1980’s) A timeless classic that is far and away my favourite game of all… Read more »